University of Winchester
Education Studies (Early Childhood Studies)
ES 2307 Theorising
Progressive Education
Week 5:
Last
updated 26.10.09.
Introduction
Austrian
theorist – named himself an anthroposophist and/or a Spiritual Scientist
Originally
member of Theosophy Society (leader for several years)
·
Theosophy
(God-wisdom) a revival by Madame Blavatsky of a Greek non-theistic movement. Believed
all religions are attempts to reach the Absolute, indicating the importance of
humans’ spiritual character and quest for spiritual knowledge.
·
Theosophical
beliefs are an amalgamation of elements of ‘truth’ from various world religions
(immortality, reincarnation, social ethics etc.) Members attempt to reach truth
through spiritual ecstasy and mysticism
Steiner
split formally from the Theosophy Society in 1912 (he prioritised Christian
thinking in his version of theosophy) and developed his ideas of
·
Anthroposohy
(anthorpos – Sophia) Wisdom of Man
·
Geisteswissenschaft
Spiritual Science
Two
terms used interchangeably, although the literature about Steiner tends to use
Anthroposophy
Combination
(or alchemy) of spirituality and science because ‘materialism understands
nothing of matter and spiritualism nothing of the spirit’ (Steiner, 1954)
Attempt
to ‘close the gap’ left by theology, physiology and psychology: all of which
have a specific field of focus
Spiritual
science argues that there are no frontiers to human knowledge, although this
may appear so if there are limits to our perception
Aims to
build bridge between visible world of nature and the invisible world of spirit
The
highly abstract nature of his ideas, and their ‘foreignness’ to a rationally
based culture can make his writing appear rather obscure
‘[Steiner’s writing is] difficult and obscure to the
point of exasperation for the casual reader’ (Childs, 1991: p. 2)
Contextualising Information
·
Members
of Human Nature
·
Epochs
of Development
·
Temperaments
Proper
pedagogy can arise only out of thorough knowledge of human nature, and
particularly child nature
‘ … the whole of human life contains
within it the seeds of its own future; but if we are to tell anything about
this future, we must first penetrate the hidden nature of the human being.’
(Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 2)
Four Members of Human Nature
·
Physical
Body
·
Etheric
Body (Life Body)
·
Astral
Body (Sentient Body)
·
Ego
Human
nature has four ‘members’ (aspects) which ‘unfold’ or ‘reveal’ themselves
during the course of a person’s life
‘Life in its wholeness is like a plant. The plant
contains more than what it offers to external life; it also holds a future
condition within its hidden depths. One who views a newly leafing plant knows
very well that eventually there will also be flowers and fruit on the
leaf-bearing stem.’ (Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 2)
Physical body – in common with all of the
mineral kingdom, this is a combination of substances subject to the laws of the
mineral world
world (Childs 1991)
Etheric Body (life
body) - what
distinguishes us from inanimate minerals
The
vital force that bring life to the body (in common with plants and animals)
bringing about the forces of growth, reproduction etc. (Steiner doesn’t include
‘death’)
Human
etheric body differs from that of plants animals in that it is organised to
serve the purposes of the thinking spirit also (Childs 1991)
‘It is therefore the builder and shaper of the physical
body, its inhabitant and its architect.’ (Steiner, 1907/1996)
Astral body
(sentient body)
- what distinguishes us from plants
Vehicle
of emotions that are absent in creatures consisting only of physical and
etheric bodies: pain, pleasure, impulse etc.
Extension
beyond responding physically to a sensation to reflecting on that stimulus in
an inner process (Childs 1991)
Cannot
simply be explained in terms of matter – consists of active forces and astral
body deviates in both size and shape from the physical body
Ego (the body of
the ‘I’) -
not shared with any other earthly creature
Body of the I is the higher soul of mankind, making humans the kings
of earthly creation
Force of
individualisation: that which guarantees the uniqueness of every person
‘Working outward from itself it [the I] has to ennoble and purify the other members of human nature’
(Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 11)
Task of
the ego is to purify and ennoble the other three members of Man’s nature
The ‘I’
is the soul’s central core (Steiner 1910/1994: p. 61)
Incarnation and Reincarnation
The ‘grave
prejudice’ of modern materialist science is to try and explain the spiritual
qualities of a person being by hereditary transmission from parents/ancestors
Our
physical qualities come from our parents/species – as spiritual entities we
have our own shape (Childs 1991)
‘I’ is
eternal
Ego
evolves to higher and higher stages of development through successive stages of
re-embodiment
Life on
earth is a continuation of life in spiritual worlds
‘Growth’
and ‘development’ of the child a process of gradual incarnation: descent of the
spiritual entity into the world of matter
Parents
do not ‘create’ their offspring – they merely provide the vehicle for the
spiritual being seeking re-embodiment
Destiny
is self-created – and so most children choose the parents they are born to
(Childs 1991)
We have
the possibility of achieving freedom if we comprehend both dying and becoming
If we
focus only on dying we would be unable to move forward
The Four Members and Life Epochs
Educator
works with the four members of the human being, which do not develop uniformly
Correct
foundation for teaching involves a knowledge of these
laws of human nature and development
Four Life Epochs
Development
divided in roughly 7 year periods
|
Epoch |
Starting Age |
Process of development |
|
1st
Epoch |
Birth |
Child’s
physical body is liberated from the mother and enabled to interact directly
with the environment Body,
soul and spirit of the child are in complete unity |
|
2nd
Epoch |
2nd
dentition |
Liberation
of the etheric body |
|
3rd
Epoch |
Puberty |
Liberation
of the astral body |
|
4th
Epoch |
Maturity
(approx 21 years) |
Liberation
of the ego |
First Epoch
Forces
of heredity are at work only in the
first epoch
Physical
birth liberates the child from the mother and enables to the child to interact
directly with the environment
Child
makes no differentiation between himself and the environment, and instinctively
imitates the world around him
The
spirit is present, but unconscious. The soul is present, but dreaming (Childs
1991)
Etheric
body is preparing for its liberation, and until this occurs there should not be
excessive call on the child’s powers of thinking/memory
‘Before the change of teeth occurs, the free life-body is
not yet at work in human beings.’ (Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 16)
Etheric
body is working to free itself and second teeth are created by the etheric body
(rather than inherited by the physical body)
Main
task of the educator during this epoch is to ensure the harmonising of the spirit
and soul within the physical body: the educator must provide an environment
that is worthy of imitation
‘The task of the educator, declared Steiner, is to
develop that part of the child’s spirit which is not yet perfect, and that part
of the soul which is still less perfect. In terms of pedagogy this means the
education of the will (through the limbs), and partly educating the feeling of
life (through the rhythmic system). Direct education of the intellect or
thinking life is virtually impossible; one cannot implant intelligence that is
not there, one can only awaken those faculties already in the child, but
sleeping.’ (Childs, 1991: p. 40)
Second Epoch
Etheric
Body (soul and spirit) is freed from the physical body and child can begin to develop
its own inner nature
Freeing
of etheric forces means that they can be used to serve the body in a different
way and become forces of mental representation: formation of concepts is now
possible
Child
begins to differentiate self from environment and to seek an authority
Third Epoch
Only
after freeing of astral body is child able to apply his own judgement to the
world
Fourth Epoch
Liberation
of the ego, characterising the individuality of the person
Four Temperaments
Doctrine
of four temperaments has Greek foundation
|
Greek |
Steiner
added these |
|
|
Choleric |
Fire |
Blood |
|
Sanguine |
Air |
Nerves |
|
Phlegmatic |
Water |
Glands |
|
Melancholic |
Earth |
Physical
body per se |
Before
the age of puberty, the overriding temperament of all children is sanguine
Overriding
temperament of the adolescent and young adult is choleric
Middle
life is melancholic
Old age
is phlegmatic
Our
temperament is the result of the interpenetration of our astral body and ego
(representing the ‘cosmic’ stream of soul and spirit) and of our physical and
etheric bodies (representing the ‘earthly’ stream of heredity).
Manner
of interpenetration means that one member predominates over the other three
Temperaments in the classroom
Teacher
should always work with a child’s basic temperament and never against it
Group children
according to temperament: this enables them to grow bored of their similarity
and explore other ways of being
Cholerics
and Phelgmatics should be kept apart by grouping the sanguines and melancholics
between them
Melancholic
Attention not easily aroused,
|
Phlegmatic |
Choleric |
|
Attention easily aroused, Least strongly persevering |
Attention most easily aroused, Most strongly persevering |
Sanguine
Attention easily aroused,
Little strength of perseverance
Teacher’s own temperament
Teachers
must strive after self-knowledge and work to suppress any extremes of
temperament while they are with their pupils (Childs, 1991: p. 62)
Appropriate Pedagogy
Children
must know with their whole being. The teacher must help the child at all times
to permeate his faculties of cognition with feeling and with will. The child should
never feel a separation between spirit and body
‘The great aim at the
Activities
in the classroom must start from knowledge of the child
‘In educating, what the teacher does can depend only
slightly on anything he gets from a general, abstract pedagogy: it must rather
be newly born every moment from a live understanding of the young human being
he or she is teaching.’ (Steiner, 1919/1985: p. 4)
Knowledge
of the special needs of each life period provides the basis for drawing up a
suitable curriculum.’ (Steiner, 1919/1985)
Education in the First Epoch
Infant
children are messengers from the spirit world (Childs, 1991: p. 67)
Feelings
of deep reverence on the part of the teacher should accompany this descent into
the physical world (Steiner, 1944: p. 15)
Child in
first epoch is a sense-organ: he surrenders himself to the environment, and
everything makes an impression upon him
Child
must develop slowly into the world, with the teacher as enthusiastic mediator
and protector
Every
opportunity should be taken to instil in the child feelings of gratitude to the
higher worlds by developing his/her sense of awe and wonder
Two ways
in which children in the first epoch enter into relationship with their
environment
·
Imitation
·
Example
‘ … as the muscles of the hand grow firm and strong
through doing the work for which they are suited so the brain is guided into
the correct course of development if it receives the proper impressions from
the environment.’ (Steiner, 1996: p. 19)
Young children
are able to learn so readily through imitation because they experience the
world with complete openness, proceeding from the basic assumption that the
world is good. Therefore teachers must always act in ways that are worthy of
imitation (Petrash, 2000)
‘The children who live in [..]
an atmosphere of love and warmth, who have around them truly good examples to
imitate, are living in their proper element. One should thus strictly guard
against anything being done in the children’s presence that they should not
imitate.’ (Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 22)
The
world should be regarded as a work of art – to attain real knowledge of the
world the intellect must marry scientific understanding with artistic
experience
Waldorf
Kindergarten
(Petrash 2000)
Part kitchen, part playroom. Restful colours, simple furniture, toys/play are structures
usually wooden.
Primary
duty to provide suitable opportunities for child to imitate
Use of
rhythm and repetition to ‘aid healthy development’ (Oldfield, 2001)
Teachers
intentionally work in the presence of children and important tasks are assigned
a day in the week
‘Work’
for children should be restricted to imitating adults’ ordinary activities
Task of
all schools gradually to lead the child over from play to work, and the basis
of this should be the imitation of the real work that adults do (Steiner, 1988)
‘A Steiner Waldorf
Kindergarten is like an extended family. The day and its activities have a
regular rhythm and structure from the children’s arrival until their departure.
There is a balance between the daily work that needs to be done, caring for the
house, baking bread, doing the washing and so on as well as handicrafts, such
as simple weaving, carving, embroidery and sewing. There is sweeping to be
done, leaves gathered up outside and even a little garden to attend. The of
course there are the festivals to celebrate, stories to be told, songs to be
sung and games to be played. Last and by no means least, there is time for
creative play both indoors and outdoors.’ (Clouder and Rawson, 2003: pp. 41-2)
Education in the Second Epoch
At the
change of teeth, the etheric body can be worked upon through instruction
Children
can now take guidance from the inner meaning and value of things
Key
qualities of this stage are discipleship and authority
‘Formation and growth of the etheric body means the
shaping and developing of inclinations and habits.’ (Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 23)
The
tendency to imitate diminishes and the child has a profound longing for
authority as s/he begins the process of differentiating from the environment
There is
still no teacher intention to implant content
Child in
this epoch seeks to comprehend the world by socialising with others and
learning through them (not assimilating concepts directly). Until puberty
children should be storing in their memories the treasures of thought on which
mankind has pondered. Later intellectual understanding will penetrate this and
illuminate this
Artistic
education awakens the intellect and the teacher’s task is to develop an
authoritative approach within an artistic relationship of leader and led
(Childs, 1991: 85)
‘Much can be done with the simplest resources, if only
the teacher has the proper artistic feeling, joy, and happiness in living, a
love of all existence, a power and energy for work – these are the lifelong
results of the proper cultivation of a feeling for beauty and art.’ (Steiner,
1907/1996: p. 35)
Education in the Third Epoch
Abstract
moral maxims in education are appropriate only when astral body is liberated
‘The intellect is a soul-force only born with puberty,
and we should not try to influence it in any way externally before this time.’
(Steiner, 1907/1996: p. 31)
Teachers
help to develop powers of discernment
‘The ability to observe, compare, analyse and synthesise
helps young people better understand the world they are inheriting and at the
same time, prepares them for finding their place in the world.’ (Petrash, 2003:
p. 83)
In-depth
study
Truth,
Beauty and Goodness
References
Childs,
G. (1991) Steiner Education in Theory and
practice
Petrash,
J. (2003) Understanding Waldorf
Education: teaching from the inside out
Steiner,
R. (1907/1996) The Education of the Child. Early Lectures on
Education
Steiner,
R. (1910) cited in Childs, G. (1991) Steiner
Education in Theory and practice
Steiner,
R. (144) cited in Childs, G. (1991) Steiner
Education in Theory and practice